Alabama-LSU produces lowest TV rating for national championship in BCS era |

“The Honey Badger doesn’t care…he takes what he wants.”

This is the phrase commonly associated the cornerback Tyrann Mathieu in an attempt to describe his fearless and attacking approach to football.

Monday night, apparently, it more aptly described the general attitude towards the BCS National Championship Game between LSU and Alabama.  As in, “The honey badger doesn’t care…and neither do the fans of college football or casual sports viewers or sponsors or even the LSU offense, which forgot to show up.

Yesterday, revealed what many suspected–that viewers were not tuned into Monday night’s rematch between the two SEC schools:

Overnight ratings for Alabama’s 21-0 victory over LSU were the lowest for a national championship in the 14-year history of the BCS. The All-SEC affair, the first championship pairing teams from the same conference, drew a 13.8 overnight rating on ESPN. The previous record low was a 14.3 for Miami-Nebraska at the 2002 Rose Bowl.

Theories abound as to why the ratings were so low, even in light of the projections that ratings would be low for this particular matchup:

  • ESPN aired the game and is a premium cable package–meaning that viewership would take a hit in this recession-stilted television market.
  • LSU and Alabama played once during this season.  Viewers are uninterested in a rematch game.
  • This game was billed as a battle of defenses and viewers prefer more scoring.

I actually offer an additional explanation: Injustice.

The last championship game to get such a low rating (Nebraska and Miami in ’02) was also marked by a measure of injustice.  Nebraska did not play in its own conference championship game. Yet due to BCS computer averages, Nebraska was computed into the championship game over two-loss Colorado (who already beat Nebraska) and one-loss Oregon.  Viewers cried foul and apparently backed up their frustration by not watching the game, a 37 to 14 shellacking at the hand of Miami.

Monday night’s game appears to have been affected by the same sense of injustice–an important and influential perception factor when dealing with Millennials.  Younger viewers (who, by the way, are the target market for these contests) by-and-large believe the BCS to be an unjust system and that either a retooled system or playoff system are preferable options.  When the championship game is viewed as part of an unfair system and when the two teams don’t appear to be the best two teams, and when the two teams have already played, and when the two teams only play defense–you have the perfect concoction for a stinker of a television event.

Apparently, if only one side of the ball shows up then viewers prefer that it be the “offensive” side (irony, no?)  The Valero Alamo Bowl received the highest non-BCS bowl audience ever for ESPN, which is the same network that aired the national championship.

The “ESPN is a premium channel and we are in a recession” argument is bunk.  Baylor-Washington attracted 5.1 million viewers on a Thursday night before New Years and was fighting the best lineup of programming on television.  The BCS title game scrounged up 16 million watchers when it was the prime feature on a bland Monday in January.

The Alamo Bowl did not fight injustice.

The Alamo Bowl brought offense to the table.

I think it is time for a  playoff.

About Doug Hankins

Although not a Christian in his youth, Doug came to believe in Jesus during his teenage years. When not playing sports or pastoring Doug is probably spending time with his wife, reading a good book, or drinking some hot tea. Doug's first book Dawson Trotman: In His Own Words is available wherever books are sold. You can follow Doug on twitter.
This entry was posted in Culture and tagged . Bookmark the permalink.

7 Responses to Alabama-LSU produces lowest TV rating for national championship in BCS era |

  1. URL says:

    Have read a couple of of the articles on your web site now, and I truly like your style of blogging. I added it to my favorites blog web site list and will probably be checking back soon. 473246

  2. Ceres says:

    i wish i could write as well as you do in your blog, congratulations.

  3. Alexsandra says:

    it sure helped me a lot as well. this is not an easy topic, but you make it easy to be understood. thank you so much!

  4. learn guitar says:

    I like this web site so much, saved to my bookmarks .

    • Nisha says:

      LSU-Alabama Rematch in BCS Title Game Shouldn’t Happen Regardless of What Midwest Sports FansNeither article eseronds the idea of a championship rematch, but both articles (along with several others) serve to legitimize the debate. Clay Travis, of Outkick the Coverage and 104.5 in Nashville, has been an outspoken advocate of a title-game Another game for the ages looms in TuscaloosaBoston.comAnother game for the ages looms in TuscaloosaNews Courierall 194 news articles

    • Unique says:

      Baylor kicking a game-winning field goal with arnoud one minute left to upset TCU after the Horned Frogs had scored 25 fourth-quarter points to take a 48-47 lead, now that was sweet! TCU was probably the closest thing college football had to a national champion last season. It went 13-0, won the Rose Bowl after the arbitrary rules of the BCS kept it out of the so-called national championship game and, unlike Auburn and Oregon, is NOT being investigated at the moment by the NCAA. People need to chill out and let them play ball. For example, did you hear that Pac-12 Commissioner Larry Scott was meeting with the media in Dallas before Oregon’s loss to LSU. Not a good weekend for the Pac-12 when you throw in UCLA’s loss to Houston and Oregon State’s stunning overtime loss to Sacramento State. I heard that Scott told reporters that we should expect to see further consolidation given the fragmentation of college sports. Seriously, the Big 12 will soon be as obsolete as the typewriter if Scott has his way. A year ago he was ready to pounce on Texas and try to turn his league into a 16-team behemoth before anyone else could make a similar move. Now, that chance may come again in the next few weeks. Don’t expect Scott to be passive if it does.Anyhow, I just wanted to add my 2cents. I enjoy your football commentary. It’s always good to see tahr some people still h e a love for the game and not the media spectacle surrounding it. Your fan!wonderboy26

  5. Fantastic website. Lots of useful info here. I am sending it to a few buddies ans additionally sharing in delicious. And certainly, thank you to your sweat!

Comments are closed.